Baseballism Return Policy: A Simple Guide for Hassle-Free Returns
Baseballism return policy simplified! Know when you’ll get a refund, how exchanges work & the trick to free returns.
Baseballism is a lifestyle brand rooted in baseball’s heritage, known for its stylish and sporty gear that celebrates America’s pastime. Whether you’re shopping for yourself or gifting a fellow fan, it’s good to know how their return policy works—just in case the fit or feel isn’t quite right.
Here’s everything you need to know about Baseballism Return Policy.
Baseballism Return Policy Overview
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Return Window | No time limit for store credit/exchange. Refunds only if return is within 6 months. |
| Condition of Items | Must be unworn and in original condition for return/exchange. |
| Return Shipping (U.S.) | Free only if you purchase “Free Returns + Package Protection” at checkout. |
| Return Shipping (Intl.) | Customer pays for return shipping. |
| Refund Method | Original payment method (if within 6 months) or store credit. |
| Third-Party Purchases | Exchange or store credit only – no refunds. |
| Gift or In-Store Returns | Must contact Baseballism directly. |
How to Start a Return or Exchange
Returning or exchanging something at Baseballism is pretty straightforward. But there’s a small twist: whether or not your return is free depends on what you selected during checkout.
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Gather Your Info
You’ll need your order number and the email address you used to place the order. - Visit the Returns Portal
Go to Baseballism’s Return Portal to begin your request. The screenshot of the page shared below
- Select What You Want to Return or Exchange
- If you’re exchanging, you can choose your new item right on the site.
- For returns, just select the items you want to send back.
- Download and Use the Return Label
- If you paid for Free Returns + Package Protection, your return label is free.
- If you didn’t select that option, you’ll have to cover the return shipping cost yourself.
- Drop Off the Package
Ship your return using the label provided. Your exchange will ship out after your return is received and scanned.
Baseballism cannot upgrade shipping speeds for exchanged items.
Returns & Exchanges: What You Should Know
No Questions Asked Policy
Baseballism proudly offers a no-questions-asked return policy. They just want you to love your gear.
Return Windows Explained
- You can return items anytime for store credit or exchange—no matter when you purchased.
- But if you want a refund to your original payment method, your return:
- Must be from an order less than 6 months old
- Must arrive and be processed within that 6-month window
- For orders older than 6 months, you’ll still be able to exchange or get store credit.
Exchanges Made Simple
When you go through the online return portal:
- You’ll get to choose your new item(s) right there.
- Once your original return is scanned by the carrier, they’ll ship your exchange using standard shipping.
- Shipping upgrades are not available for exchanges.
Condition of Items
Your return or exchange will be accepted as long as:
- The item is unworn, and
- Still in original condition.
Do You Get Free Return Shipping?
Yes—but only if you choose it at checkout.
Baseballism offers free, no-questions-asked returns on all U.S. orders, including continental U.S., Alaska, and Hawaii. But here’s the key:
| At Checkout, Did You Choose… | Result |
|---|---|
| “Free Returns + Package Protection” | You get a free return label. |
| Didn’t choose that option | You’ll have to pay return shipping. |
So if you’re ordering from anywhere in the U.S.—yes, even Alaska and Hawaii—you’re covered for free returns only if you selected the right option at checkout.
Refunds: What to Expect
If you’re going for a refund, here’s what to know:
- Refund Method: Original payment method (for eligible orders).
- Refund Timeline: Typically takes up to 2 weeks after your return reaches their warehouse.
- Busy Season Warning: Around holidays and major sales, expect longer delays.
- Shipping Charges: Not refunded, sorry!
- Older Orders:
- If the order is less than 6 months old → You can get a full refund to your original payment method.
- If it’s over 6 months → You can still get store credit or make an exchange, but not a refund.
Also important: Refunds must go to the original card. You can’t switch cards or refund to a different account.
Returning a Gift or Store Purchase
Bought something in-store or got it as a gift?
- Reach out directly at believe@baseballism.com for help.
- If your item came from a third-party vendor (like an MLB team store):
- You can only exchange it or get store credit.
- No refunds for third-party purchases.
International Returns
Live outside the U.S.? You can still return or exchange items—but there’s one catch.
- You’ll need to pay for the return shipping yourself.
- To get started, email believe@baseballism.com and they’ll give you full instructions.
Third-Party Purchases (MLB Stores, etc.)
Bought your Baseballism gear from a third-party vendor?
You can’t get a refund—but you can:
- Exchange the item for something of equal or lesser value, or
- Get store credit.
Just don’t expect cash back for these.
How to Contact Them for Help
If you’re confused or just want a real person to help you out, here’s how to reach Baseballism:
- Email: believe@baseballism.com
- Phone: (503) 206-6738
- Returns Portal: baseballism.com/apps/redo/account/login
They’re known to be friendly and helpful, so don’t hesitate to reach out.
Common Questions
Final Thoughts
Baseballism’s return policy is surprisingly generous and simple—as long as you understand the details. The biggest thing to watch for? Whether you selected the Free Returns + Package Protection at checkout. If you did, your return is a breeze. If not, expect to pay for return shipping.
Still not sure what to do? Drop them an email or give them a quick call—they’re happy to help.
If you want to return something to Baseballism, just follow the steps above—and don’t stress. You’ve got options!
Please Note: Return policies can change over time. While this article aims to provide accurate information based on the policy at the time of writing, it’s always a good idea to double-check the return policy on official Baseballism website for the most up-to-date return policy details. For any specific questions or situations not covered here, the official website or contacting Baseballism Customer Service directly is the best resource.
